One night the killer strikes again, and this time his victims are a professor at Hampton college and a woman named Joan Bemis, whom the Creeper seems to know.
The police manage to corner their suspect in an apartment house; in order to escape, the Creeper enters the apartment of a young woman named Helen (Jane Adams). Because Helen is blind, she isn't repelled by his appearance. He asks for her help, and she agrees, saying that she has a gift of sensing a person's true nature. When the police knock on her door, she tells them that she hasn't seen anyone suspicious in the area.
Helen knows only that she's met a man who is in some sort of trouble, and she is certain that he is innocent of whatever he's been accused of. For his part the Creeper is glad to know someone who doesn't scream and run away when he enters the room, and a rather unlikely friendship ensues.
Soon enough the Creeper has murdered a delivery boy who brought groceries to the waterfront storage shed he's been living in. Here the police discover an old newspaper clipping of three college chums, circa 1930: Clifford Scott, Virginia Rogers and Hal Moffat.
When the police look for Clifford Scott and Virginia Rogers they discover the two are now married; and that the third person in the photo, Hal Moffat, was Clifford's college roommate as well as a rival for Virginia's affections. The late Joan Bemis was also a close friend of the trio. A star athlete, Hal's face was hideously disfigured in a lab accident. The accident seems also to have affected his "glands and nerves", not to mention his mind; because all these years later Hal has decided to get revenge on all those who spurned him in college.
Meanwhile, learning that Helen needs $3,000 to pay for an operation to cure her blindness, Hal decides to get her the money -- even though he knows that she will be repelled by him if she's able to see him. Nevertheless, he goes to Clifford and Virginia and demands money. Clifford gives him a box of expensive jewelry, but manages to put a couple of .38 slugs into him before he's murdered himself.
Wounded, Hal delivers the jewelry to Helen, determined that she go ahead with the operation. But when the police find her and tell her who she's befriended, she agrees to help them find their quarry. Angered at her public betrayal, he decides that Helen too must die....
Comments: The Brute Man was produced by Ben Pivar, the same man responsible for Universal's previous Rondo Hatton vehicle House of Horrors. From that film Pivar brought back the writing / directing team of Dwight Babcock and Jean Yarborough, but this is somewhat less successful outing than House of Horrors was.
There are several reasons for this. First, while the character of The Creeper is intriguing, Rondo Hatton simply isn't strong enough an actor to carry a lot of screen time on his own, and his menacing presence gets diluted if we see too much of him. This problem was elegantly side-stepped in House of Horrors, which had as its primary antihero Martin Kosleck's tormented artist; Hatton's Creeper served both as the artist's muse and as his means of retribution. Most importantly, the Creeper was the catalyst for everything that happened in the movie, giving the artist a reason to believe that vengeance, of which he had dreamed for so long, might actually be possible.
Here, instead of an artist, the Creeper befriends a beautiful, pure-hearted blind girl who conveniently focuses on the inner beauty of those around her. This plot device was already an old chestnut in 1946, and was clearly a bid to make the Creeper sympathetic, like the monster in Bride of Frankenstein or Peter Lorre's disfigured watchmaker in The Face Behind the Mask. But no matter how you slice it, a man who snaps people's spines whenever he gets annoyed isn't going to generate a lot of sympathy from the audience. Helen's statement that she can sense that Hal is good at heart is laughable, considering just what the Creeper has been up to; it seems to be a case of the screenwriters wanting to have it both ways -- a remorseless killer who is -- somehow or other -- simply misunderstood.
Another problematic departure from House of Horrors is the insertion of an origin story. This is a bad idea to start with, because the Creeper is an intriguing character partly because he is so enigmatic. We don't know where he comes from, why he looks the way he does or why he kills so indiscriminately -- and no explanation is going to be as good as what we dream up on our own. To make matters worse, the story presented isn't remotely plausible, and isn't even interesting except that it parallels in some ways Rondo Hatton's own story. The character of Hal Moffat is shown to be a handsome college football star who is Clifford Scott's romantic rival. Clifford foils Hal's scheduled date with Virginia, forcing Hal to stay late after chemistry class, mixing various corrosive acids in glass beakers. In a flash of temper, Hal smashes one of the beakers on the lab bench, causing him to be permanently disfigured.
In real life, Rondo Hatton was a popular and handsome college athlete; it is often claimed (though I can't confirm) that he was voted "Most Handsome" by his high school peers. Like Hal, his grotesque appearance came relatively late in life, though not as the result of a lab accident but by a glandular disorder called acromegaly. Over a number of years Hatton's features became increasingly coarse and grotesque, until his face and body became a carnival-sideshow grade of ugly.
There's no denying that this movie is itself a carnival sideshow of sorts, as the audience is invited to pay money to gawk at Hatton's misfortune. It's been claimed over the years that this apparent attempt to cash in was exploitative and unsavory. And that's true so far as it goes. But it's important to remember that exploitation of this kind wasn't seen as a big problem in the 1940s. Nor was it considered wrong to deny employment to someone with a physical deformity like the one Hatton endured. For some people in those days, taking money to be stared at was the only living they could make, poor as it often was. So in that context Hatton probably had a better time of it than others with his affliction. He was, after all, in the movie business, and many people have done far more humiliating things for a chance to be in pictures.
The Brute Man would prove to be Hatton's final screen role; he died after shooting completed but before the film was released. Universal, which was in the midst of a merger with International Pictures, had resolved that these sort of B-pictures were better suited for the Poverty Row studios, and The Brute Man was sold off to PRC for distribution.
The sale of The Brute Man basically marked the end of Universal's dominance of the horror genre. It's unfortunate that the studio had let its horror entries become so threadbare. But it's just as well that the studio stopped making more films of this kind -- films that were little better than the dreck PRC and Monogram were grinding out. And Universal would rise to prominence again a decade later with the William Alland-produced science fiction films, many of which had elements of horror about them. Those films still lay in the future for viewers of Horror Incorporated.
